Monday, April 28, 2008

Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening - by Robert Frost



Whose woods these are I think I know.
His house is in the village, though;
He will not see me stopping here
To watch his woods fill up with snow.

My little horse must think it queer
To stop without a farmhouse near
Between the woods and frozen lake
The darkest evening of the year.

He gives his harness bells a shake
To ask if there is some mistake.
The only other sound's the sweep
Of easy wind and downy flake.

The woods are lovely, dark, and deep,
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep.

Questions:
1. Make up questions you have about the poem you just read, and type them as a new comment.
2. Notice how much more descriptive Robert Frost's poem is, than the one about the Red Wheelbarrow from the last blog. Find the "So Much Depends Upon" poem you added as a comment in the previous blog, and re-write it in your new comment, including more detail about WHY so much depends on the thing you wrote about. INCLUDE YOUR NAME AT THE END BEFORE SUBMITTING!

25 comments:

Anonymous said...

What is up with
the snowy woods
poem today?

Why doesn't the person just
keep going if he's got
so many miles to go
before he sleeps?

And why do I have to tell more
about the blue car
splattered with mud
speeding down the road?

I don't want to
write about that blue car
that had miles to go
before it slept,
so many miles to go
in such a hurry.

JACK
Room 105-Miss Stretchberry

Anonymous said...

1. Why does he have to go many miles before he sleeps ?

why is the horse little? Why doesen't he just get a car so he can go faster?

How did he know whose woods it is?

Why do u stop at the tree?

Why don't you go ealier so it won't be dark when you arrive?

David

Anonymous said...

1. Why is this person traveling while he's trying to sleeping?

2. What happened to the horse and where is it now?

3. Why did he write the first sentance and whats hte point of it when he already knows. Also why is there not a question mark for the sentance.

4. Why is there a bell in the woods and why is he in the woods anyway?

Andy#0

Anonymous said...

1. Where is he going? And what promises does he have to keep if he has to go through the woods at night? Why does he have to go on for miles,he should rest for a while,because then his brain will be refreshed and he can keep going.
Dea

Anonymous said...

1. What kind of promises could this person have? How is he going to fulfil these promises by going into the woods? Where could he be going on that horse?

Rahul

Anonymous said...

#1 Why did Robert Frost rhyme in his poem?

Why did Robert decide to write about a farm or country side?

Why are the words in his poem not regular? For example " whose woods these are" That doesn't make sense it should be who lives in these woods.

SpIrOo

Anonymous said...

What do you mean that you have promises to keep(what type of promises) and that you have to go so far just to sleep?
Why could you just not sleep there and go later?
Where do you actually want to go?
Why do you want to go in to the woods to fulfull those promises?

Mohammad

Anonymous said...

#1.
Why would he go riding his horse in the darkest evening of the year?

What kind of promises does he have to keep?

Momin

Anonymous said...

1.why is he riding a horse at the darkest evening of the year?

why is he stopping if he has so many miles to go?

Jay

Anonymous said...

#2.
The Pencil

So much depends
upon

an orange,sharp,staples
pencil

scratching across the blanc white
paper

leaving tiny scrapes of
led behind.

Momin

Anonymous said...

2.my oringinal poem,
So much depends
upon

groups of digging
worms

eaten by flying
hawks

in the busy
zoo.

My revised poem ,

So much depends
upon

handfuls of digging
worms

feasted by gliding
hawks

among the crowded
zoo.

Lot's of things depend on worms because they're are viewed as disgusting but they're are vital towards our survival .

Without the worms , the birds and other things will die of hunger and so the birds will be extinct.

Worms eat grass so the grass with overpopulate and cows will also overpopulate and eventually all the cows ate all the food and dies.

Other herbivores will also overpopulate so they will all be extinct with grass , birds and us!

We would have no food left!!!!

David

Anonymous said...

#1
If you don't know where you are why would you keep going?
Why would you trespass on someone else's property?
If you don't feed your horse it'll get slower and slower and wouldn't you be stuck in the cold for a longer amount of time?
Why would you ask who's woods your in?And if you don't know, shouldn't you get out?

Adam

Anonymous said...

#2
So much depnds on
the shiny PS3

dressed in a black coat

the smoke in jamed entertainment

Yang

Anonymous said...

So much depends
Upon

The wet rain that rains down in the pouring night

To be drank by a person to live or suvive

And to be there when
it's needed

Andy#0

Anonymous said...

2.So much depends
upon

on the redest fire
truck

loading the coldest
water

leaving vast tracks on
roads.

from Jay

Anonymous said...

Why he go so many miles to go before he sleeps?

How he know house is in the village?

What is the promises he keep?

Vicky

Anonymous said...

why does the the charcter use a horse and not his own feet?
If he knows who owns the woods than why doen't he just tell us?


Yang man

Anonymous said...

So much depends
upon
a brown house
painted with colour insde
with living people.
by:Thiviyan
revised poem,
So much depends
upon
a brown house splattered with mud dirtand old paint
painted with colour inside like a beatiful rainbow but too much dirt
with living people being sheltered
Thiviyan

Anonymous said...

The Knife

so much depends upon

A black cutting knife
Giving people a simple life
slicing all the food
cutting cucumbers with a dive

fixing a cooks mood,
preparing a dish thats good

Rahul

Anonymous said...

2.My Bicycle

so much depends
upon

a speeding bicycle
going down the
hill

colours whizzing and
flashing by

riding it on hot
summer days after
days

pedaling faster and
harder each time
the cool air
in my face
and hair

Dea

Anonymous said...

The Bike


so much depends
upon

a orange,speedy,greasy,humongus
bike

sprayed with black,slimy,gooey,
oil

speeding down the steep,bumpy,black,paved
hill

Mohammad

Anonymous said...

#2 so much depends
upon

an intelligent,elegant
author

making the narative
good

writing and writing
about

what should be
understood

by SpIrOo again

Anonymous said...

Why on earth do we need to know whose woods these are in the begining of the poem ? If the poem is about the owner's woods then shouldn't the title be like THE OWNER'S WOODS,not only that but shouldn't the fisrt verse or the first sentence should be important ? To me the first verse doesn't seem important.An second of all why would somone ride a horse in the dark woods ?Don't they know thats usualy a warning signal saying "somethings bad going to happen, and if you don't get out you'll be sorry", Come on, didn't the writer give this person a brain!

Anonymous said...

Why on earth would we want to know who these woods belong ? If the poem is about the wood's owner then shouldn't the title be The WOODS OWNER,instead of STOPPING BY THE WOODS ON A SNOWY EVENING ? And besides, don't the first verse or sentence tell you about the poem or story ? Not only that, but why would the person walk in the woods when its dark ? Come on, most of the time when you walk through the dark woods,its like a warning signal saying "don't come here,go back or you'll be sorry!"Didn't the writer or poet give this person a brain!

Rachel

Anonymous said...

ORIGINAL:
So much depends
upon

the hot sun

showing its brightness to everyone

and shining in our faces.

REVISED:
So much depends
upon

the fire blazing sun

mysteriously appearing its uphold beauty to all living creatures and organisims

and showering us with sparks of lava towards our awwed faces,as if it were more valuable then life itself.

I chose to do the sun because without the sun there would be no life, and if there was no life there would be not one single human on earth.The sun is a major part of our life and is also at the top of every food chain,because we rely on the sun to provide us heat ,light and food.With the sun and its help from its cousins (the stars)we were able to have and build civilization.So the sun is like our God or chief (litteraly speakin of course)would the natives say,but I think we all agree we people of today would like to call the sun a resource.So all in one,THE SUN RULES!!!!